Monday, August 31, 2020

Manhunter: The Special Edition - Extras


Manhunter: The Special Edition
1999

Foreword
by Archie Goodwin
New York, NY
Oct 9, 1979

Archie Goodwin writes about how he came to be the editor of Detective Comics for just over a year from mid-1973 to mid-1974. Batman was the feature character but he couldn’t do anything wild and crazy with him. Goodwin started to develop a story which wasn’t originally supposed to be about the return of a third tier golden age character.

Walt Simonson didn’t seem to Goodwin like the right choice to draw the story until he saw a war story he drew about the Battle of the Alamo. Goodwin and Simonson’s collaboration on Manhunter was always a joint effort. They worked Marvel-style. Goodwin didn’t, for the most part write scripts or panel descriptions. He left page layouts to Simonson.

Goodwin accepted a job at Warren Publishing before the story was complete. Julie Schwartz, who was going to replace Goodwin on Detective Comics, had no interest in keeping the Manhunter character around. Goodwin agreed to stick around long enough to finish off the story.

The story won awards for both Goodwin and Simonson. The first and fifth chapters were named short story of the year for 1973 and 1974, respectively. The final chapter was named feature length story of the year for 1974.

Afterword
by Walt Simonson
New York
Feb 1999

Archie Goodwin returned to DC Comics in the early 1990s. Someone at DC suggested that he and Walt should do a new Manhunter story. Archie and Walt weren’t interested until a few years later when Archie came up with an idea for a new story. They hashed it out and Walt started to work on it, did research, compiled reference material, but he didn’t get very far with the story itself. It sat incomplete for years and then Archie passed away.

Louise, Walt’s wife, suggested that he finish drawing the story. It would be a silent story. Archie had never written a script. All that Walt had was some notes he has taken while talking to Archie. 

I am a bit surprised that there is no mention of Klaus Janson’s contributions to the story in the Foreword of the Afterword.

Manhunter: The Final Chapter
by Archie Goodwin, Walt Simonson, and Klaus Janson

Christine St. Clair and Asano Nitobe have come to Gotham. They are hunting someone that looks just like Manhunter, most likely one of his clones. The Gotham City PD and Batman don’t catch up to them until St. Clair and Nitobe have dealt with the clone, the last of the clones.

Thoughts

The only words in this story are sound effects. The story has a very different feel to it than the original. There are only a couple pages that have more than 6 panels per page. Most of the panels are rectangular. The story is set in Gotham which contrasts greatly from the original which had a very international feel to it. The story takes place at night and seems to take place on a single night.

I presume that if Goodwin and Simonson had done the story as originally intended then it would have been longer than this. There probably would have been more than one setting and St. Clair and Nitobe would have dealt with more than just one clone.

This is a fun addendum to the Manhunter story. It doesn’t feel necessary but I enjoyed it and I like to think that I would have enjoyed it even more if it had been completed within Archie Goodwin’s lifetime.

No comments:

Post a Comment