Wednesday, November 24, 2021

Detective Comics 500.1

Detective Comics (1937) 500
Mar 1981

To Kill a Legend
by Alan Brennert, Dick Giordano, Adrienne Roy, John Costanza, Paul Levitt

Batman is called upon by the Phantom Stranger to save the Thomas and Martha Wayne of another world from being killed. Robin (Dick Grayson) goes with him. Batman is convinced that saving the Wayne’s is the right thing to do. Robin questions whether they have the right to interfere in the natural course of events. Will this world be better without a Batman? Will the Bruce Wayne of this world turn out worse because his parents aren’t killed?

Batman and Robin make some assumptions based on what they know happened on their world but things don’t turn out exactly the same.

Thoughts

I’m pretty sure I’ve read this story before. I bought this issue decades ago. I can’t remember exactly when but I think it was in the early to mid-1980s. I'm pretty sure that I didn’t buy and read it when it first hit the newsstands and comic shops.

This story holds up fairly well. I found the dilemma Batman and Robin face to be quite well portrayed. I believed that they were really unsure what the correct course of action was.

Notes

This is the first of several stories in this over-sized, milestone issue. Not all of them are Batman stories.

Most of this story takes place on Earth-5 according to DC Database. This is the only appearance of Earth-5. The Earth-5 versions of the Waynes, Lieutenant James Gordon, Barbara Kean (Gordon’s fiancĂ©e), Lew Moxon, and Joe Chill are all in this story. Gordon is of course the future commissioner of the GCPD.

Lew Moxon of Earth-1 was a crime boss who hired Joe Chill to kill Thomas and Martha Wayne, as revealed in Detective Comics 235 (Sep 1956). That was his only appearance prior to Detective Comics 500. There doesn’t seem to have been a Lew Moxon on Earth-2.

Joe Chill of Earth-2 first appeared in Detective Comics 33 (Nov 1939). He was killed in Detective Comics 47 (Jul 1948), his second appearance. He has shown up in flashbacks in a number of comic books.

Joe Chill of Earth-1 (aka Joseph Chilton) made a number of appearances prior to Detective Comics 457 (Mar 1976) which is listed as his first appearance in DC Database, which is confusing. He was killed, like his Earth-2 counterpart, by other criminals.

No comments:

Post a Comment